Sustaind.org is sick. :( If you're a PHP programmer, can you help us upgrade Sustain'd and get it working again? If interested, email richard AT moregoodfoundation DOT org.


The true stories of how American troops, killed in Iraq, actually died keep spilling out this week. On Tuesday, we explored the case of Kenny Stanton Jr., murdered last month by our allies, the Iraqi police, though the military didn’t make that known at the time. Now we learn that one of the first female soldiers killed in Iraq died by her own hand after objecting to interrogation techniques used on prisoners. Peterson, a devout Mormon, had graduated from Flagstaff High School and earned a psychology degree from Northern Arizona University on a military scholarship. “Peterson objected to the interrogation techniques used on prisoners. She refused to participate after only two nights working in the unit known as the cage. Army spokespersons for her unit have refused to describe the interrogation techniques Alyssa objected to. They say all records of those techniques have now been destroyed. ...

comments

The whole thing seems suspicious. Consider the evidence:

- The U.S. gender ratio for suicides is 4:1, male to female

- She was a "devout" member of the Church which opposes suicide

- She was a return missionary indicating she was even more likely to follow the tenets of the religion including looking forward to temple marriage and being a mother

- She had just attended suicide prevention training

- She had a psychology degree

- Of all education levels, those with some college are least likely to commit suicide (compared to those with some high school and some with a high school degree)

- Her parents never knew about her opposition to the interrogation techniques

Highly unusual.
written by gospelcougar 746 days ago
I'm fascinated in what you find highly unusual about her suicide. Do you have an alternative explanation?
written by canadiancynic 746 days ago
Well, I'm not gospelcougar, but I've heard others express the same doubts, and the two other explanations I've heard are that she was accidentally killed by another soldier, but the military wanted to cover up the accident, or that she was killed to keep her quiet about something. I do think being devout LDS makes it difficult to square with suicide, but mentally ill people don't do what seems logical or normal to most. However, it sounds as though there was no evidence she was mentally ill, as far as her family knew.
written by sootica 745 days ago
"I do think being devout LDS makes it difficult to square with suicide,"

Devout latter-day saints don't commit suicide?
written by loydo38 745 days ago
Of course devout LDS folks do commit suicide, but I would guess that it would be more unusual among believing LDS folks for several reasons. But if she did have some kind of mental illness, then I don't think that religious affiliation can really overcome mental illness.
written by sootica 745 days ago
I have to side with loydo38. Unless I see evidence otherwise, I do not see why devout LDS would be any less likely to commit suicide than non-devout LDS. Suicide more often than not happens because of depression. Once in a state depressed enough to seriously consider suicide, I doubt one's upbringin will play much of a factor.
written by kmsiever 735 days ago
Allow me to state the obvious: good Mormon girl, believes a patriotic thing to do that can "help others" is to join the military. She arrives in Iraq, sees people torturing innocent Iraqis, objects, is told that she's now being "unpatriotic", "unrealistic", "doesn't understand these backstabbing people". She's learned enough Arabic to recognize her superiors and other torturers are wrong about most of these people. She now is faced with a crisis of the way things are supposed to be and the reality she is living and being told that she is bad for having a conscience. She is driven to severe mental illness and depression and commits suicide. Meanwhile, Mormons back home who have mostly never been exposed to most of these pressures find it far more comforting to deny the obvious than face it.
written by NonArab-Arab 729 days ago

log in to comment or register here.

who opposed this story


What's Sustain'd?

Sustain'd is a place where people can submit and "sustain" their favorite LDS-oriented web pages. Blog posts, photo pages, church articles, you name it.
read more...

Search Sustain'd

Sustain'd Tools

RSS Feeds